I think it's just a matter of semantics; Jughead can't actually
be an incident, it's a bomb, not an event. It can cause the Incident. There's probably nothing more to it than that.
I also believe pretty strongly in WHH, but there's one thing bugging me: if Jughead caused the Incident, wouldn't an H-bomb destroy the entire Island? Not to mention Dr. Chang, who we know was alive after the Incident, was (IIRC) on the Swan site during the explosion. I don't see how he'd survive an H-bomb blast that close. And of course, this makes one wonder why Richard said he
saw the Losties die....
I'm sure this has been discussed to death so long ago I can't find the threads, but if anyone could fill me in on the current consensus, I'd be happy

Bookmarks