When Ben told the truth.

[pion]

Ben doesn't always lie. I know of two occassions where he told the truth.

1. When he told Juliet he could have her sister healed of her cancer and when he told her he had.

2. When Jack asked him (on flight 316) "Did you know Locke committed suicide?" Ben answered "No, no I didn't."

Any others?

[campari]

not many lol

[The Smiley-Faced Balloon]

He told the truth about Jacob, he told the truth about Locke having a communion with the Island, he told the truth to Jack that he'd want to return to the Island (a mobisode). He told Sun that Jin was alive, he told Penny why he was going to kill her, and he wasn't lying when he said "I always have a plan".

[myfourletterlie]

He tells the truth once he's been cornered and it's his last resort, I think.

[pion]

He told the truth about Jacob, he told the truth about Locke having a communion with the Island, he told the truth to Jack that he'd want to return to the Island (a mobisode). He told Sun that Jin was alive, he told Penny why he was going to kill her, and he wasn't lying when he said "I always have a plan".

I'll give you the Jacob (He told some of the truth),

Locke/communion (Iffy but I'll give it to you),

Jack, how would he really know that. I'd say more of a guess or prediction.

Sun very questionable at this time. Alive when? He was alive in 2004. But IS alive? Iffy. WAS alive, true, but too easy.

Penny (obvious),

His plan, no. We may never know if he always has (had) a plan.

That's 5.

[Blackadder]

He tells the truth once he's been cornered and it's his last resort, I think.

You broke the code!

[MegaNice9]

More truth:

1. He came back to the island to be judged.
2. He stole Alex as a baby from an insane woman.
3. Dan Norton was his lawyer.
   
   ...There's got to be more than this. *wracks brains* Okay, got some more!
   
   
4. The Stephan King book, Carrie is really depressing.
5. He taped over the Red Sox game.
6. He genuinely wanted milk with his cereal.

Okay. That's about it.

[KilgoreTrout]

Ben doesn't always lie. I know of two occassions where he told the truth.

1. When he told Juliet he could have her sister healed of her cancer and when he told her he had.

We don't know if he or the island had anything to do with this.

2. When Jack asked him (on flight 316) "Did you know Locke committed suicide?" Ben answered "No, no I didn't."

Any others?

How was he telling the truth here?

[myfourletterlie]

He eventually told Locke who his spy on the boat was and about Charles Widmore.

[pion]

More truth:

1. He came back to the island to be judged.
2. He stole Alex as a baby from an insane woman.
3. Dan Norton was his lawyer.
   
   ...There's got to be more than this. *wracks brains* Okay, got some more!
   
   
4. The Stephan King book, Carrie is really depressing.
5. He taped over the Red Sox game.
6. He genuinely wanted milk with his cereal.

Okay. That's about it.

Judged? Maybe. I'll give you that. 6

Alex, I don't think that at any time Danielle was insane. She was a normal woman reacting to an insane situation.--still 6

Lawyer, 7

Carrie, too much of a judgement call. And very unimportant. still, not a lie. 8

I don't remember the tape over so I'll give you that one 9

milk-that's stretching it. I gave you Carrie. Not this one. 9

We don't know if he or the island had anything to do with this.

Good point. down to 8

How was he telling the truth here?

He knew he killed Locke so he did not know Locke committed suicide. Still 8