Mafia XXV - Happily Ever After? A Return To Storyville

[diggler]

Right now, I'm leaning more toward voting JM. He doesn't seem to be putting up much of a defense given the glaring accusations. Like TR said earlier after the BWIT debacle, I would expect more of an impassioned, hot-blooded defense if we were unjustly looking at lynching a civvie.

[lostaddict12]

Originally Posted by TokyoRose

It’s not just Aldo, many suspect you and several people confused the tin man thing. LC finds CN suspicious but not Aldo and DRD for this. You find Aldo suspicious for this but not DRD or CN.

I never said I found Aldo suspicious. I asked for clarification on the reasons for his opinions, and I couldn't help but notice how strong those opinions of his are. Many suspect me, but Aldo is just really relentless, even repetitive. I think it's his playing style though-- I haven't played a game with him for a while but I do remember that when he has a suspicion he sticks to it like crazy-gorilla-glue. In the post I was responding to though, he flat out wrongly accused me of being the first to imply Tinny was blocked, after Shinny had narrowed it down and others had come to the conclusion already.

Originally Posted by Aldo

Lots of good posts I see.... Good stuff. At this point I absolutely will be voting for lostaddict12. She has no defense and is just pinging the living sh*t out of my pingometer. Nothing in this game is a guaranteed sure thing but my gut feel, my game experiance, Kyle/LA12's posts, and a majority of other players point to one fact.......lostaddict12 is a babbie. We can't all be wrong. I hope that Lostaddict12 gets lynched......then the proof will be in the Lynch Post. If I am wrong, if we are wrong.....well, I will pay the penalty....whatever that may be. I was all set to take Kyle out..... Something else happened and he was sparred and LA took over..... Sorry, but as I said before.... A babbie is a babbie is a baddie.

All indicators point in LA12's direction.. Let's make this quick.

Dude, I think you've gotten your point across, geez... and lol @ babbie

Again you give no concrete reason for being so sure. The whole case against me seems to be based on generalities, gut feelings, etc. Everyone keeps wondering why I haven't made more of a defense--nobody's given me anything to defend against!

Originally Posted by Dharma Ranch Dressing

Now, wait just a minute, Rose...my comment was taken out of context...as was my defense of my comment and you think that's suspicious and worthy of making me a lynch candidate. Fine, whatever.

But LA says something that also can be read two different ways and it's a "helluva stretch". Rose, you're very observant...your a smooth operator...I don't have a read on who's side you're on. But you seem to have your mind made up awfully quick and are sticking to it.

Where did Rose say it made you worthy of the lynch? I didn't read her comment as being that strong of an accusation. Overdefensive much?

[Aldo]

Originally Posted by Dharma Ranch Dressing

However, I agree with diggler's point above. If JM is the apprentice, then it would not only validate Pinocchio's assertion (which, I admit is problematic) but it would also allow us to know exactly who JM is...and if he's the apprentice then we know we're one step closer to landing a major fish. Can we trust Pinocchio? Not 100%, but this could be a great opportunity here...and I don't think we should pass it up.

In conclusion, if I had a vote, it would go to Jason Maher. I would still not trust LA one bit. And if she is, in fact, lynched...I will completely understand why...and I'll hope and pray she's a bad guy. However, consider the very circumstantial evidence I've laid out above before casting your vote...and consider what might be gained if JM is the apprentice and we lynch him.

Hmmmmm..... I read what you wrote and I understand what you said. I guess I don't agree nor do I see how we get closer to a big fish.

Assume for the sake of argument that you are 100% correct. That Pinocchio is spot on. What do we have... A baddie with no powers that can affect a civvie! Yay! A bddie dies but it the weakest baddie of them all.

Thus, assumning that lostaddict12 is also a baddie, an idea that you believe and touch on, that would mean that she is NOT the Apprentice and would be a baddie with far greater powers. See the logic....yes..

So, on one hand we have a baddie with no powers (lynch save, but still dies) vs. a baddie with greater powers. I say go for the baddie that can directly hurt civvies...

If and when the DS gets lynched, the Apprentice will still die and then we will know who the DS is....yes?

The Apprentice can also be taken out via a Night Kill... eliminating the DS Lynch Save...

No....I say take out lostaddict12, she is the safer bet and had a higher likelyhood of being a baddie with powers that can and will affect civvies...

[ADDICTEDTOTHESHINDIG]

I am headed out the door to the Springsteen concert now ....

Just a reminder that I will likely be in no condition to write the lynch post when I get home .. if I am, great, but chances are that I will have had a few beers too many ...

You can expect it sometime tomorrow morning my time ...

[guyswherearewe]

I'm voting LA for the many reasons i've already said. I agree with Aldo on this. I'm going with my gut and thinking that LA is a better lynchee than Jason.

*votes*

[Aldo]

Originally Posted by lostaddict12

The whole case against me seems to be based on generalities, gut feelings, etc. Everyone keeps wondering why I haven't made more of a defense--nobody's given me anything to defend against.

Wrong... the primary case, and ultimately your death, was caused by Kyle....not you...but, your replies have not helped the situation one drop...in fact, they have hurt you considerably

"Everyone keeps wondering" = Exactly..... it's NOT just one person... ..... thanks for confirming

Gorilla Glue you say.... nah....it's just when I pick up the scent *sniff sniff* of a baddie.....I go all out....unlike the Minnesota Vikings defense....I never miss a tackle....

So LA...... the jig is up...

[Tranquility]

You do realise The Dark Sorceress and The Apprentice are on different teams right, Aldo?

[Aldo]

Originally Posted by ADDICTEDTOTHESHINDIG

I am headed out the door to the Springsteen concert now ....

Just a reminder that I will likely be in no condition to write the lynch post when I get home .. if I am, great, but chances are that I will have had a few beers too many ...

You can expect it sometime tomorrow morning my time ...

Have WICKED fun Shinny.....

*no drinking allowed*

[Aldo]

Originally Posted by Tranquility

You do realise The Dark Sorceress and The Apprentice are on different teams right, Aldo?

Yes....I was just going to correct that.... thanks....

*is old, forgets*

The point is still EXACTLY the same....

[diggler]

Originally Posted by Aldo

Assume for the sake of argument that you are 100% correct. That Pinocchio is spot on. What do we have... A baddie with no powers that can affect a civvie! Yay! A bddie dies but it the weakest baddie of them all...
So, on one hand we have a baddie with no powers (lynch save, but still dies) vs. a baddie with greater powers. I say go for the baddie that can directly hurt civvies...

If and when the DS gets lynched, the Apprentice will still die and then we will know who the DS is....yes?

The Apprentice can also be taken out via a Night Kill... eliminating the DS Lynch Save...

I think the apprentice is more dangerous than you're giving the role credit for, Aldo. First Off, he substitutes for THE MAST THEIF, not The Dark Sorceress. Secondly, this is ONLY for the lynch...NOT NIGHT KILLS which means if someone targets MT for a night kill, it would miss and NO ONE would die. Or maybe I'm just misinterpreting the role...

SHINNY: Would the Apprentice die in place of the Master Thief if targeted for a night kill?