Juliet is NOT dead

[Raining Tragedy]

I think poor juliet is gone

I am sad to see her go, but that is one EPIC death scene. I will be shocked if she is alive in S6.

[asdf]

I think everyone will just flash to 2007.

Juliet will still be severely injured inside the imploded Swan's ruins, and probably die after having some final words with Sawyer. All that in the very season premiere.

That would be a very satisfying ending of Juliet, at least for me.

[Sawyers_Stash]

Originally Posted by Raining Tragedy

I think poor juliet is gone

I am sad to see her go, but that is one EPIC death scene. I will be shocked if she is alive in S6.

Thats why I think she has to be gone actually.

I mean how can you top that epic scene with any other last I love yous? I mean her being pulling away by magnets to her death...pretty rad death scene. If ya gotta go thats the way to go.

[MM0602]

To me her scene in The Incident, if she is dead, is the one death scene that makes me the most creeped out out of all the deaths on the show. Just something about being pulled into a hole and somehow surviving but knowing you're going to have to lay there and slowly bleed to death by yourself is super disturbing and although it does make for a cool exit I feel like she was cheated by life I guess. She deserves to see her sister again and to be happy with Sawyer. But I guess that makes it all the more tragic, huh? Still I hope she somehow lives, though I'm starting to doubt it.

[Sawyers_Stash]

Oh it was disturbing. Horror movie style death.
I gotta say though I never expected her to see her sister again whether she lived through this thing or not. But maybe if the bomb plan worked...

[MM0602]

But it's just sooo sad XD she has to see her sister! I feel like every other main character who dies gets their redemption in the end...

Boone: he was finally able to let go of Shannon
Shannon: found someone that she loved and loved her back (arguable I suppose)
Ana: "I can't do this anymore", let her true feelings out instead of acting tough
Libby: ok she's too mysterious, I guess we could say she moved on from her husband's death with Hurley though
Eko: came to terms with his choices in life
Charlie: changed from self-interested druggie to someone that gave his life for his friends and family (Claire and Aaron)

I guess Charlotte and Daniel had pretty crappy finishes too. (Edit: oh yeah, and Locke) But come on, Juliet's entire life, at least all we've seen in flashbacks and on the island, has been horrible! She deserves something happy She made some crappy choices in the finale and she gets killed for it! That's too unfair for Lost.

Long live Juliet! ...ok I'm done. XD

[twenty-three]

Originally Posted by MM0602

But come on, Juliet's entire life, at least all we've seen in flashbacks and on the island, has been horrible! She deserves something happy She made some crappy choices in the finale and she gets killed for it! That's too unfair for Lost.

Long live Juliet! ...ok I'm done. XD

Well... she DID get three beautiful and happy years with Sawyer... that's, at least, something.

[Kaosium]

You do not detonate a nuclear device with a rock and live to tell the tale. That's beyond the realm of willing suspension of disbelief.

She might very well turn up later, in flashbacks, or as a ghost, or even alive if Twitchy and Jack were right and they were able to undo things. However Juliet died when the bomb exploded, there's nothing that could mitigate a point-blank nuclear explosion. Nothing.

[Ambient Virus]

Originally Posted by Kaosium

You do not detonate a nuclear device with a rock and live to tell the tale. That's beyond the realm of willing suspension of disbelief.

This is Lost we're talking about here.
Although I'm pretty sure she'll die from this incident, whether it's immediately or gradually

[Kaosium]

Originally Posted by MM0602

But it's just sooo sad XD she has to see her sister! I feel like every other main character who dies gets their redemption in the end...

Actually, I think they all died pointlessly, in fact I think it's a theme. Charlie drowned himself in order to create the conditions where Claire would leave on the helicopter--but she never did. They're all like that. Boone's death is entirely pointless, the plane has no relevance whatsoever to the hatch, which is why he was there in the first place, his conversation with Bernard does nothing but influence Ana's growing paranoia. Shannon is shot when Ana-Lucia makes the bizarre decision to use her only bullet to shoot an unarmed blonde chick, hardly the definition of a threat. Mikhail's death is stupidity personified: by doing what he did he precluded all chances of reversing the situation for the Others. John died and became a vehicle for killing Jacob, which I would assume wasn't a goal of his. Daniel died proving the opposite of his last theory. Charlotte, Naomi--all pointless deaths.