04x02- "Confirmed Dead" (Questions, Theories, Discussion)

[lostaddict12]

So, Charlotte Staples Lewis, yet another literary allusion

[OceanicSix815]

Originally Posted by Simplton

Hmm I never thought of that, good mind my man!

I'm a woman, by the way. ha

[HenryGale666]

Originally Posted by Simplton

Why am I the only person that wants Ben to die?

Because love or hate him, he adds spice that noone else does... personally, i also think he might be less evil than whoever sent this freighter... pure speculation on my part

Originally Posted by OceanicSix815

I can't believe nobody has brought this up yet...it leads me to believe that there must have been an explanation during the show that I didn't notice but everyone else did...

why was Frank all scratched up, climbing up that cliff, with his sat phone cracked.....if he safely landed the helicopter?! did they ever tell us something that happened to him??

yeah, thanks for bringing that up... i was wondering that too, but i guess in the dozen other 'huh?' moments i had, this one got lost... if he landed it as smoothly as he says, it doesn't make a whole lot of sense... maybe he met the polar bear or the black death (smokey)???

Originally Posted by lostaddict12

So, Charlotte Staples Lewis, yet another literary allusion

Hmm, CS Lewis... author of the Narnia series... where Narnia was only accessible from the real world through a sort of portal in a wardrobe... i wonder if they're trying to tell us something...



btw, Eli Stone may blow, but damn is Natasha Henstridge ever smoking hot! I hope she's next off the freighter!

[Dharma Ranch Dressing]

I haven't had a chance to really read everything on this thread, hope this hasn't been mentioned too much: but does anyone else think that Ben was NOT lying when he said he didn't know about the smoke monster?

[l2aiNonU]

Originally Posted by OceanicSix815

I can't believe nobody has brought this up yet...it leads me to believe that there must have been an explanation during the show that I didn't notice but everyone else did...

why was Frank all scratched up, climbing up that cliff, with his sat phone cracked.....if he safely landed the helicopter?! did they ever tell us something that happened to him??

Right, when it first showed him, I was thinkin' how it looked like he had been on the Island for a while. It doesnt really add up, If he was able to land safetly, why is he beat to hell and back?

[estaman]

Originally Posted by Simplton

They used Vincent like a slave, I wonder if they will get him back. Yeah I thought of Eko right when I saw that picture. I don't think Mike is the man Ben was talking about but I do think he is on the freighter.

That was my first thought as well, "How could they sacrifice Vincent just to get rid of the GPS tracker?!?!?!? They could've just tossed it and took off." Whoever wrote that in the series has obviously never had a dog OR a Lab, for that matter.

[Locke N Load]

Originally Posted by HenryGale666

btw, Eli Stone may blow, but damn is Natasha Henstridge ever smoking hot! I hope she's next off the freighter!

hahahaha...nice

[OceanicSix815]

Originally Posted by Dharma Ranch Dressing

I haven't had a chance to really read everything on this thread, hope this hasn't been mentioned too much: but does anyone else think that Ben was NOT lying when he said he didn't know about the smoke monster?

I've definitely wondered that.


Also, can someone tell me if it's been confirmed that the powder is keeping Jacob trapped? Or is that still just a theory

[kc_09]

It does seem odd that Frank was climbing up a cliff, badly injured if he did manage to land the helicopter safely. Why wouldn't he have just stayed in/around the chopper?
Also, the footage we see at the beginning of the episode really seems like whoever those explorers were, actually did stumble on to the wreckage - as if there really is a tangible "815" down there

[DeBarlo]

Originally Posted by HenryGale666

Hmm, CS Lewis... author of the Narnia series... where Narnia was only accessible from the real world through a sort of portal in a wardrobe... i wonder if they're trying to tell us something...

Narnia has Lions and ice queens while the island has polar bears and Ben. Not much different.